5 Places on the North Fork That Make Ice Cream From Local Ingredients

Talk about farm-to-cone; Harbes Family Farm offers sweet corn soft-serve. • Photo courtesy of Harbes Family Farm

The North Fork is well known for its farm-to-table food movement—and that extends to its ice cream as well. Whether it’s local farms, specialty shops or ice cream parlors, the North Fork offers up some of the best ice cream, using farm grown produce, local honey, and fresh herbs. Think of it as farm-to-cone.

1. Harbes Family Farm

Harbes Family Farm’s Homemade Strawberry Soft Serve Ice Cream

Harbes Family Farm has been growing produce on the North Fork for generations. They sell their homemade ice cream from their farm stand in Mattituck. Right now they’re serving strawberry, but in late July the flavor will switch to corn. Owner Ed Harbes has mastered a way to make real corn custard.

“First the corn is roasted, then small bits are almost liquefied and incorporated into the custard base, which we use in our soft serve machine,” Mr. Harbes explained. “On a summer day, people really enjoy the flavor.”

Custard is made with milk, cream, and egg yolks, which has a creamier texture and smoother consistency than ice cream. Harbes’ corn custard is available during corn season, which usually runs til the end of October.

Harbes Family Farm is located at 715 Sound Avenue in Mattituck.

2. The Ice Cream Patch

The Ice Cream Patch: Lemon Basil, Strawberry Fields, and Blueberry Bliss

From strawberries to mint to sugar snap peas, the Ice Cream Patch makes ice cream flavors from whatever’s growing in the fields of Patty DiVello’s Mattituck farm, Patty’s Berries & Bunches.

Conceived by Patty’s daughter Jennifer DiVello as a way to educate consumers about when produce comes into season, Jennifer and partner John Pastore make flavors like lemon basil, cocoa mint, and blueberry bliss from lemons, herbs, and blueberries grown on the farm. Available only when produce is in season, their flavors change throughout the year.

“The sugar snap peas ice cream is about to run out because I’m out of peas,” Patty DiVello said. “Cucumbers are coming in, then blackberries and peaches are next. In the fall we’ll have pumpkin, apple pie and maple walnut made with New York maple syrup.”

The Ice Cream Patch can be found at Patty’s Berries & Bunches at 410 Sound Avenue in Mattituck and at Revel North Fork at 28100 Main Road in Cutchogue.

3. North Fork Chocolate Company

North Fork Chocolate Company’s Ice Cream Sandwich

Don’t call North Fork Chocolate Company an ice cream parlor. Because of their proximity to the wineries, this Aquebogue chocolatier describes itself as more of an ice cream tasting room.

While they do serve ice cream in cones and ice cream sandwiches, it’s the tasting flights that make their ice cream experience so distinct. Tastings can be up to four different ice creams and include flavors like strawberry buttermilk, sea salt almond chocolate, and blueberry ginger sorbet.

Chef and Chocolatier Steve Amaral uses local ingredients like strawberries from Sujecki Farms in Baiting Hollow, blueberries from Goodale Farms in Aquebogue, coffee from Aldo’s of Greenport, and salt from Cutchogue’s North ForkSea Salt Co.

“We partnered with Goodale Farms to make the ice cream at the farm with Goodale’s milk and eggs right in the room where they pasteurize the milk,” co-owner Ann Corley said.

North Fork Chocolate Company is located at 750 Main Road in Aquebogue.

4. North Breeze Farms

North Breeze Farms/Shade Trees’ Honey Ice Cream

At Shade Trees Nursery in Jamesport, they make and sell their own food line under the label North Breeze Farms. That line includes their own honey and now a honey ice cream.

“I already pour honey on my ice cream at home, so why not incorporate it into the making of it,” owner and beekeeper Lisa Caracciolo said.

The ice cream has a vanilla base, with North Breeze Farms’ honey added as the sweetener. Ms. Caracciolo sells it by the pint in their farm shop.

“I was trying to come up with a catchy name, so we named it “Bee Happy Ice Cream,” she said.

Bee Happy Honey Ice Cream is available year-round. The next flavor on the horizon is pumpkin, which Ms. Caracciolo made last year from fresh pumpkin. It was so popular, she’s already planning to bring it back in the fall.

Shade Trees Nursery is located at 1875 Main Road in Jamesport.

5. Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe

Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe’s Peconic Swamp Thing

Open since 1953, Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe is a Riverhead institution. Owner Stu Feldschuh takes advantage of the abundance on the North Fork by incorporating many local ingredients into his ice cream.

“I get all my stuff from Briermere Farms,” Mr. Feldschuh said. “Right now we have local blueberries, we also have a lot of strawberries and raspberries. Everything is homemade and I always have at least one flavor of the week.”

The flavor of the week is promoted on Snowflake’s Facebook page and they’re well known for creating unusual flavors like peanut butter and jelly for the beginning of school and their cannoli ice cream, which was featured on The Food Network.

Another popular flavor is Peconic swamp thing, made with chocolate ice cream, fudge brownie, and raspberry. Snowflake’s banana split is still made using the original 1953 recipe, that includes homemade banana ice cream, two kinds of cherries and walnuts.

Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe is located at 1148 West Main Street in Riverhead.

This story was originally published in 2018.